Halloween Would You Rather

by

Share a laugh with a friend!

Embark on a spine-tingling adventure with our Halloween Would You Rather questions. Dare to decide between spooky scenarios, creepy choices, and ghostly dilemmas. Perfect for parties, gatherings, or a fun night in, these questions promise to add a thrilling twist to your Halloween festivities

feature image in orange background, white text saying "halloween would you rather questions"

Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Kids

  • Would you rather have a pumpkin for a head or have skeleton hands?
  • Would you rather carve a pumpkin or paint a pumpkin?
  • Would you rather collect candy in a pillowcase or in a bucket?
  • Would you rather wear your Halloween costume to bed or to school for 10 days straight?
  • Would you rather eat all of your Halloween candy right away or only eat one candy every day for a year?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather go to a pumpkin patch or a corn maze?
  • Would you rather trick-or-treat in your neighborhood or a new neighborhood?
  • Would you rather judge a pumpkin carving contest or a pie baking contest?
  • Would you rather have every day be Halloween or never have Halloween?
  • Would you rather be able to fly on a broomstick or have a magic wand?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather dress up as something scary or something silly?
  • Would you rather carve a pumpkin or bob for apples?
  • Would you rather want to be a superhero or a villain for Halloween?
  • Would you rather have a monster in your closet or a ghost under your bed?
  • Would you rather go trick or treating with your friends or watch a scary movie at home with your friends?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather have a real magic wand or be able to fly on a broomstick?
  • Would you rather want to have a werewolf as a friend or have a vampire as a friend?
  • Would you rather sleep in a room full of spiders or sleep in a room full of snakes?
  • Would you rather dress up as Cinderella or Ariel?
  • Would you rather only eat chocolate or only eat gummy candies for the rest of your life?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather be able to transform into a bat or a black cat?
  • Would you rather get a Snickers or a Twix bar in your candy bag?
  • Would you rather watch a scary movie or watch a funny movie?
  • Would you rather wear a mask or paint your face?
  • Would you rather be Spiderman or Batman for Halloween?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather have the ability to talk to ghosts or have the ability to turn invisible?
  • Would you rather dress up as Wonder Woman or Captain Marvel?
  • Would you rather make a magic potion or drink a magic potion?
  • Would you rather dress as a mummy with toilet paper or a ghost with a bed sheet?
  • Would you rather meet a vampire or meet a werewolf?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text

Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Tweens

  • Would you rather have vampire teeth or a witch’s mole on your nose?
  • Would you rather eat a sugared spider or eat a fried snake?
  • Would you rather trick or treat in the pouring rain or below freezing temperatures?
  • Would you rather be chased through a creepy amusement park or a dark forest?
  • Would you rather be invisible like a ghost or fly like a witch?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather go trick-or-treating with your friends or get paid to take a kid trick-or-treating?
  • Would you rather have to wear a creepy costume every day for a year or eat only Halloween candy for a month?
  • Would you rather carve five giant pumpkins or 50 small ones?
  • Would you rather take a potion that turns you into someone else for a day or one that makes you crazy lucky for a day?
  • Would you rather have a toad as a best friend or have a black cat as an enemy?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather be trapped in a cave of bats or stuck in a pit of spiders?
  • Would you rather be the only one in a costume at a party or the only one without a costume?
  • Would you rather eat dog food with sugar, or eat snails with garlic butter?
  • Would you rather eat a caramel apple or a caramel popcorn ball?
  • Would you rather be in the middle of a zombie survivalist movie or a murder mystery movie?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather stay at the Hotel Transylvania or the Monster House?
  • Would you rather watch Ghostbusters or Beetlejuice?
  • Would you rather eat extremely sour warheads or hot tamales?
  • Would you rather do the thriller dance in public or howl like a werewolf in your backyard?
  • Would you rather stay home to give out candy or go trick-or-treating?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text

Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Students

  • Would you rather be a real-life Vampire or Werewolf?
  • Would you rather wear a baby costume or a costume that you can’t walk in?
  • Would you rather be locked in a room with giant rats or giant spiders?
  • Would you rather dress up as a cat or dress up as a mouse?
  • Would you rather only have Halloween or only have Christmas?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather be scared or scare someone?
  • Would you rather eat pumpkin pie or apple cider donuts?
  • Would you rather write a scary story or write a funny story?
  • Would you rather dress up as a character from Harry Potter or Star Wars?
  • Would you rather attend a school for magic or a school for supernatural beings?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather spend the night with friendly ghosts or friendly monsters?
  • Would you rather tell your friends what you’re going to be for Halloween or keep it a secret until Halloween night?
  • Would you rather be a famous ghost hunter or a famous monster hunter?
  • Would you rather have a talking cat or a talking owl?
  • Would you rather get 3 pillowcases full of random candy or get 1 pillow case of your favorite candy?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather eat Smarties or eat candy corn?
  • Would you rather have a Halloween party or a Christmas party?
  • Would you rather get lost in a candy forest or wake up in a candy gingerbread house?
  • Would you prefer to explore an ancient tomb or a dug up graveyard?
  • Would you rather drink apple cider or pumpkin spice cake?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text

Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Teens

  • Would you rather eat moldy candy or a handful of worms?
  • Would you rather stick your hand in a box filled with worms or not know what is in the box?
  • Would you rather Halloween costumes came to life or people’s Halloween decorations came to life?
  • Would you rather live with a dog that talks or a cat that walks on two feet?
  • Would you rather have an invisible friend or have no friends at all?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather go to a Halloween party or watch game 7 of the World Series?
  • Would you rather sleep upside down or sleep in a coffin?
  • Would you rather be a ghost or a zombie?
  • Would you rather visit a haunted house or a vampire’s lair?
  • Would you rather lick a stranger’s feet or the feet of someone you know?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather be invisible like a ghost or green like Frankenstein?
  • Would you rather speak from the back of your head or the bottom of your feet?
  • Would you rather ride a broom or fly like a bat?
  • Would you rather be kept in a zoo for people to see you or live in the wild?
  • Would you rather eat brains or eat liver?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather communicate only by whispering or talking loudly over everybody else?
  • Would you rather be a horror movie hero or a horror movie villain?
  • Would you rather have your hair pulled out or your nails plucked out?
  • Would you rather lick a public sidewalk or the bottom of someone’s shoes?
  • Would you rather have unlimited access to haunted houses or unlimited access to escape rooms?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather go to a haunted hotel or a haunted corn maze?
  • Would you rather have a talking pumpkin for a pet or a flying broomstick for transportation?
  • Would you rather be stung by a bee or scratched by a cat?
  • Would you rather get free candy from strangers or get paid to hand out candy to trick-or-treaters?
  • Would you rather own a black cat or a black bat?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather go trick-or-treating with a group of friends or by yourself?
  • Would you rather eat a raw snail or a raw snake?
  • Would you rather be able to see ghosts or communicate with animals?
  • Would you rather hear a scary cackle or bone-chilling scream?
  • Would you rather attend a Halloween party at a graveyard or at a haunted mansion?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text

Scary Halloween Would You Rather Questions 

  • Would you rather wake up in a glass coffin that slowly fills up with water or wake up in a locked room that is on fire?
  • Would you rather be featured in American Horror Story or in Haunting of Hill House?
  • Would you rather stay in a house where you hear eerie cries or where you see strange shadows?
  • Would you rather stick your hand in a jar of eyeballs or a bowl of guts?
  • Would you rather be haunted by a demon or a ghost?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather walk through a haunted house or run through a graveyard at midnight?
  • Would you rather have your mom who’s a witch or your dad who’s a vampire?
  • Would you rather watch a scary movie alone or watch one with someone who is easily terrified?
  • Would you rather be the first or the last who turns into a zombie in a zombie apocalypse?
  • Would you rather bungee jump or skydive?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather be possessed by a demon or find out that all your family members are possessed by demons?
  • Would you rather accidentally bite off the tip of your tongue or accidentally rip off your small finger?
  • Would you rather drown or burn to death?
  • Would you rather find something under your bed or behind your closet door?
  • Would you rather get attacked by a skeleton or a ghost?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather let a tarantula crawl up your arm or a snake wrap around your neck?
  • Would you rather tell a horror story around a campfire in the woods or watch a horror movie by yourself?
  • Would you rather know when you die or how you die?
  • Would you rather have no legs or no fingers?
  • Would you rather save your pet or save your worst enemy?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather see the girl from “The Ring” every time you look up into the mirror or feel something touch your foot every time you sleep?
  • Would you rather fall into a pool of blood or a nest of something creepy crawly?
  • Would you rather spend a night alone in an abandoned psychiatric hospital or spend a night alone in a cemetery?
  • Would you rather be chased by a zombie or be chased by the headless horseman?
  • Would you rather have a witch’s green skin or a werewolf’s hairy fur all over your face and body?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text

Hocus Pocus Would You Rather

  • Would you rather start living in a world of Hocus Pocus or A Quiet Place?
  • Would you rather watch Hocus Pocus or Hocus Pocus 2?
  • Would you rather be The Devil’s Wife or The Witch Mother?
  • Would you rather watch Charmed or Hocus Pocus?
  • Would you rather be Max or Dani?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather have a flying broom or never have a vacuum again?
  • Would you rather have a spell book or a witches cauldron?
  • Would you rather live where it’s always Halloween or where it’s never Halloween?
  • Would you rather trick or treat with your sister or go to a Halloween party with your parents?
  • Would you rather walk through a graveyard at night or stay overnight in a haunted house?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather have a black cat for a pet or a bat for a pet?
  • Would you rather be able to cast spells or whip up potions?
  • Would you rather be a mummy and sleep for years or a witch be able to fly on a broom?
  • Would you rather have to keep magic secret or let it be known?
  • Would you rather watch a scary movie or carve a pumpkin?

Halloween Would You Rather Family Questions

  • Would you rather see a trick or get a treat?
  • Would you rather wear something to look like a baby or wear something to look scary?
  • Would you rather dress up as a hero or as a villain?
  • Would you rather go back in time or teleport to the future?
  • Would you rather watch a scary movie or be in a scary movie?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather trick-or-treat with your friends or trick-or-treat with your family?
  • Would you rather cut off all your toes or get married into the Addams family?
  • Would you rather walk like a zombie or look like one?
  • Would you rather wear a store-bought costume or a homemade costume?
  • Would you rather play some scary pranks on your family or carve a jack-o-lantern?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather have a vampire dad or a witch mom?
  • Would you rather have no eyes or no toes?
  • Would you rather be scared or scare someone else?
  • Would you rather be a ghost in your school and scare the teachers and students or be in a zombie apocalypse?
  • Would you rather have a dentist appointment or watch a horror series?
  • Would you rather have a black cat cross your path or break a mirror for bad luck?
  • Would you rather watch the movie Ghostbusters or Beetlejuice?
  • Would you rather die suddenly and painlessly at 30 or miserably and slowly at 90?
  • Would you rather get bitten by a vampire or hexed by a witch?
  • Would you rather have hands for legs or have legs for hands?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather be chased by a zombie or be chased by the headless horseman?
  • Would you rather get egged or get all your pumpkins smashed?
  • Would you rather be a witch or a warlock?
  • Would you rather wait for the Great Pumpkin with Linus or celebrate Christmas with Jack Skellington?
  • Would you rather fly on a broomstick or cast a spell?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text

Harry Potter Would You Rather Questions

  • Would you rather go to school with Harry Potter or with Casper the Friendly Ghost?
  • Would you rather have Buckbeak or Fawkes as a friend?
  • Would you rather Be In Ravenclaw House or Be In Hufflepuff House?
  • Would you rather live in the world of Harry Potter or live in the world of Sabrina Witch?
  • Would you rather dress up as Harry Potter or Captain America?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather vomit slugs or have your farts sound like the crying of Mandrake root?
  • Would you rather Be Best Friends With Ron Weasley Or Be Best Friends With Hermione Granger?
  • Would you rather have a magic wand or an invisibility cloak?
  • Would you rather save Fred or Lupin in the Battle of Hogwarts?
  • Would you rather spend Christmas at the Burrow or at Hogwarts?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather take Potions class with Snape or Defense Against the Dark Arts with Lockhart?
  • Would you rather Attend The Quidditch World Cup or Attend The Triwizard Tournament?
  • Would you rather spend a day in detention with Snape or at Dursley’s? 
  • Would you rather fly in Mr. Weasley’s car or on a broomstick?
  • Would you rather face the basilisk from The Chamber of Secrets or Face Aragog?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather attend the defense against The Dark Arts Class or Attend Care of Magical Creatures Class?
  • Would you rather be a keeper or a seeker in Quidditch?
  • Would you rather be born as pure blood or a gifted mud blood?
  • Would you rather visit The Hogwarts Library or Visit The Hogwarts Astronomy Tower?
  • Would you rather have Hagrid as your Professor or have McGonagall as your professor?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather travel on the Knight Bus or by Floo Powder?
  • Would you rather study at Beauxbatons or Durmstrang?
  • Would you rather Shop At Magical Menagerie Or Shop At Flourish and Blotts?
  • Would you rather date Cedric Diggory or Percy Weasley?
  • Would you rather play Quidditch or play Wizard’s Chess?
  • Would you rather spend a day at Hogsmeade Village or Diagon Alley?
  • Would you rather Spend A Day With Daniel Radcliffe Or Spend A Day With Emma Watson?
  • Would you rather visit Honeydukes or Weasley’s Wizard Wheezes?
  • Would you rather have Dudley Dursley or Grawp as a cousin?
  • Would you rather fight a Dementor or fight a troll?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text

Would You Rather Halloween Candy

  • Would you rather have pumpkin seeds or candy corn for teeth?
  • Would you rather have Skittles or Starbursts?
  • Would you rather eat Halloween cookies or Halloween candy?
  • Would you rather eat a Milky Way or a Snickers?
  • Would you rather get fruity candy or chocolate candy in your Halloween treat bag?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather have a king-size candy bar of your favorite or fun-size candy bars of assorted types?
  • Would you rather eat caramel apples or candy corn every day for a month?
  • Would you rather have to eat candy that’s melted or candy that’s frozen?
  • Would you rather eat a chewy candy or a crunchy one?
  • Would you rather have Halloween candy or $25?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather get Snickers or Tootsie Rolls in your Halloween treat bag?
  • Would you rather be given a Snicker’s Bar or a Reese’s Peanut Buttercup?
  • Would you rather not be allowed to speak on Halloween or not be allowed to have candy?
  • Would you rather eat gummy worms or gummy bears?
  • Would you rather have 10 small tootsie rolls or 1 Reeses Peanut Butter Cup?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather share your Halloween candy with your parents or your siblings?
  • Would you rather eat candy corn or Smarties?
  • Would you rather eat stale candy or Brussels sprouts?
  • Would you rather find a real spider in your Halloween candy or discover all your candy has raisins in it?
  • Would you rather eat only candy corn or only fun-sized candy bars for an entire month?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text

Creepy Would You Rather Halloween Questions

  • Would you rather die bleeding out or die being set on fire?
  • Would you rather spend a night in a haunted house or haunt a house yourself?
  • Would you rather run through a graveyard at night or get stuck in a haunted house?
  • Would you rather have the ghost of someone you know appear to you or the ghost of a total stranger? 
  • Would you rather sleep in a coffin overnight or hang upside down from a tree?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather be eaten by a wolf or bitten by a vampire?
  • Would you rather walk through a dark forest on your own or walk through a dark graveyard on your own?
  • Would you rather spend a whole night in a haunted house alone or sleep in a graveyard alone? 
  • Would you rather be locked in a room full of snakes or rats?
  • Would you rather a psychopath break into your house or a serial killer?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather save your parents in a plane crash or your sibling?
  • Would you rather eat a live cockroach or play a game of Ouija?
  • Would you rather die from electrocution or from drowning?
  • Would you rather be chased by one vampire or 10 zombies?
  • Would you rather eat a human heart or a human eye?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather be eaten by fish or be eaten by rats when you are still alive?
  • Would you rather see a ghost or a spaceship?
  • Would you rather face a Zombie Apocalypse or an Invasion of 10-ft spiders?
  • Would you rather see a demon in real life or an angel?
  • Would you rather watch a horror film or get a root canal?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text

Fun Halloween Would You Rather 

  • Would you rather smell like a wet werewolf every day for a year, or have a pumpkin growing out of your head?
  • Would you rather find out that ghosts were real or shapeshifters were real?
  • Would you rather scream every time you spoke, or everyone you spoke to screamed in response to what you’ve said?
  • Would you rather have very smelly feet or toes made from candy?
  • Would you rather be trapped in a creepy circus or a creepy amusement park?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather be stolen by a witch and forced to clean her oven, or licked by a werewolf every day for a month?
  • Would you rather turn into a pumpkin or a bat every time you feel scared?
  • Would you rather give up candy on Halloween or give up Thanksgiving dinner?
  • Would you rather have the ability to build spider webs or a really long sticky tongue that shoots out of your mouth like a frog’s?
  • Would you rather eat candy at breakfast or candy at dinner?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather have noses growing all around your head, or eyes growing on your neck?
  • Would you rather eat a candy that is fizzy or a candy that tingles?
  • Would you rather have candy that changes flavor or candy that changes texture?
  • Would you rather have a never-ending supply of your favorite Halloween candy or unlimited access to haunted attractions?
  • Would you rather smell like dog food for a year or garlic for the rest of your life?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text
  • Would you rather be a mad scientist and build a monster, or a spooky witch and make spells to heal people?
  • Would you rather eat frog legs, or have frog legs instead of your own legs?
  • Would you rather ask someone to cut off your ring finger or marry someone in the Adams family?
  • Would you rather go on a dinner date with a 200-year-old hag, or kiss a toad?
  • Would you rather be a ghost who scares children or someone who is haunted by ghosts?
in post image with white background, orange border, title that says "Halloween Would You Rather..", text of Halloween Would You Rather Questions, and an image of black and orange bubble text

Share a laugh with a friend!

Leave a Comment